At the urging of her family, Louise, a young alligator, tries hard to kick her biting habit.

Although worried at first about his loose tooth, six-year-old Truman soon finds out that it is okay, and is happy to receive the dollar left to him by the Tooth Fairy after it falls out.

The tooth fairy explains how she does her job.

When his cousin Opal loses a tooth during a visit, Puddle dresses as the Tooth Fairy so that Opal's hope of receiving a shiny quarter will not be disappointed.